Author – Assistant Archivist Jacob Stickel

The Western Star, February 15, 1900 – Courtesy of the Warren County Genealogical Society, Available Online Through Ohio History Connection
In the small town of Oregonia, Hezekiah Stites, an elderly farmer, was murdered, and his house was ransacked. Stites was found by a neighbor, dead in a gruesome display with pockets turned out and valuables stolen. Rumors were flying following the murder, where a scrap of paper led to the indictment of a small “gang”. Three witnesses, two of whom were possible members of this group, perjured themselves and retracted statements. Either because they were hoping to get some of the reward money or because they were frightened into making a partial testimony. Following the trial that would see the alleged “gang” members released, a neighbor was arrested and charged with the murder of Stites. The man was said to possess property of the deceased and made odd remarks to witnesses of the murder that caused him to be seized. He would be released due to a lack of evidence, leaving many to wonder who committed this grisly murder.
In a lonely log cabin in the town of Oregonia on February 5, 1900, a tall elderly man was beaten and then strangled to death. Hezekiah Stites was an active 69-year-old farmer who maintained a plot of land with a number of pigs, horses, cows, and chickens. The land itself was five miles east of Lebanon, where the deceased would sell his wares and kept a bank account. Despite Stites using the bank rumors around Oregonia, he suggested that he kept money in his house. C.C. Emmons, a neighbor of Stites, became worried after not seeing his neighbor for a few days and approached the cabin. Emmons knocked and didn’t receive a response. Nervous on behalf of his nearly 70-year-old neighbor, Emmons broke down to find Hezekiah bloodied and strangled. Pockets were turned out, and his pocketbook rummaged through. The chest on the second floor was bloodied from the hands of the robber(s) turned murderer(s). It was concluded to be a struggle perpetuated by more than one person. Despite his age, Stites was still large enough to put up a fight. The victim was bludgeoned on the head with what was later thought to be a staff or piece of firewood. The location of these injuries was made by someone smaller than Stites. After being rendered unconscious, marks at the neck indicated that the old man was strangled, but despite this, Stites may have lived for several hours after death. With pockets turned out and pocketbooks opened, the murderer(s) ransacked chests and drawers, leaving bloodied prints as evidence. It was supposed that 100$ was stolen from the Hezekiah property.
Rumors abound surrounding the death of Hezekiah, and customers at a nearby café theorized about who could’ve done it. The crime was thought to have been done by a gang looking to rob someone they felt was vulnerable and who had just come into some money days prior. A loose note passed between people was left at the café, which was suspected to be from Newton Upton and his brother, who was alleged to have threatened the old man after a previous robbery. The younger Newton was released after a lack of evidence, but Newton remained held. Additional members of the gang were alleged to include Hessie Berger (or Hassie Bargar), William and Vernon Lewis, Robert (Bob) Harlan, and Nellie Herron. Vernon Lewis and Nellie Heron were held as witnesses who provided crucial testimony that placed the “gang” at the site of the murder. Allie was another supposed witness to the crime, but later retracted her statements and was alleged to not have understood the oath which she took to testify, and was promised part of the reward money, which at that time stood at 1300$, which was set by the commissioners. Vernon Lewis and Nellie Heron would retract their statements as well, stating that they were scared and felt frightened into testifying. Regardless of Vernon Lewis and Allie Logan’s defenses, they were both convicted of perjury; Vernon Lewis received three years. Robert Harlan would be held in the Hamilton jail for pickpocketing, and William Lewis was never found during the course of the investigation. Newton Upton and Hessie Berger were released after a successful defense.

The Western Star, February 13, 1902 – Courtesy of the Warren County Genealogical Society, Available Online Through Ohio History Connection
A pair of young men were jailed because they were caught stealing Stites’ revolver months prior to the murder, 20-year-old Clarence Ralston and 14 a 14-year-old relative. They were related to a neighbor of Stites sharing the same last name. Nicknamed Colonel Ralston on account of a military record, 60-year-old Richard Ralston inquired about the state of the investigation into Stite’s death. Whether or not Emmons was going to receive the award, and whether or not any arrests have been made. Through their discussion, Col Ralston was alleged to have made a vague threat to Emmons about talking about the murder. “Your life is dear to you and my life is sweet to me. If you know anything about the case, you’d better keep still or your life won’t be worth that” (The Western Star. (Lebanon, Ohio), 1902-06-26 Pg 2). After the sentence, Col Ralston snapped his fingers. It was alleged that Col. Ralston was in possession of an old coin that he would later part ways with. Col. Ralston alleged that his son found it in a Lebanon alley, but witnesses suggest it may have come from the Stites home. Cloth found in the possession of Col. Ralston was suggested to have come from the Stites murder. While he made an appearance in court, it would seem that evidence would be dropped against the elderly Col. Ralston. Newspaper records from the Western Star drop off at this time, and criminal records held in the Warren County Records Center and Archives are partial, concluding that an appearance was made with no conviction. Clarence, one of Col. Ralston’s sons who had stolen the Stites revolver, would die from tuberculosis in 1902 at the age of 22, and Col. Ralston would pass away at the age of 82 in 1912.
Unfortunately, we don’t know who murdered Hezekiah Stites. A few short years after the murder of the owner, the log cabin was burnt to the ground. We can only make some conclusions as to why Allie and Vernon perjured themselves during the initial investigation. The cash award may have polluted the pool of witnesses hoping to gain something from the heinous act. Murder that came to the small town of Oregonia would have created a vicious rumor mill, which may have helped create the initial case against the Uptons. Regarding this case, the Records Center and Archives has documentation from the initial trial of the alleged gang and the criminal appearance docket of Col. Richard Ralston. Clarence Ralston’s larceny of private property and the perjury charges of Allie Logan and Vernon Lewis can also be found in the archives. I would also suggest reading the old Western Star and Cincinnati Enquirer articles to come up with your own conclusion. In 1900, random acts of robbery and violence 150 yards from the nearest road in a log cabin were difficult to track; it will be a wonder what would be concluded should the crime happen today.
References
“Additional Local.” The Western Star, 15 Mar. 1900, pp. 2–2, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/26220. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Additional Local.” The Western Star, 22 Feb. 1900, pp. 2–2, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/26265. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Another Confession to Murder of Hezekiah Stites.” The Wester Star, 27 Feb. 1902, pp. 5–5, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/27148. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Bench, Bar, and Jury.” Hamilton Telegraph, 3 July 1902, pp. 9–9, https://access-newspaperarchive-com.research.cincinnatilibrary.org/us/ohio/hamilton/hamilton-telegraph/1902/07-03/page-9. Accessed 3 July 1902.
“A Blood-Curdling Murder.” The Western Star, 15 Feb. 1900, pp. 5–5, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/25917. Accessed Oct. 2025.
Common Pleas Court. State of Ohio Vs Allie Logan. Vol. 12 & 4, May 1902, pp. 3344–3347 & 3349 & 512–520 & 523–527. Case No. 3344 – 3347 & 3349
Common Pleas Court. State of Ohio Vs Clarence Ralston. Vol. 12 & 4, May 1900, pp. 324–325 & 3243. Case No. 3243
Common Pleas Court. State of Ohio Vs Newton Upton. Vol. 4, May 1900, p. 3248. Case No. 3248
Common Pleas court. State of Ohio Vs. Robert Harlan & William Lewis & Vernon Lewis & Newton Upton & Hassie Bargar & Nellie Herron. Vol. 4, May 1902, p. 3330. Case No. 3330
Common Pleas Court. State of Ohio Vs. Wilmer Blackwell. Vol. 4, May 1900, p. 3239. Case No. 3239
“Court News.” The Western Star, 17 May 1900, pp. 1–1, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/26030. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Doings of the County Courts.” The Westerrn Star, 9 Oct. 1902, pp. 1–1, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/27187. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Five Prisoners Now in Jail .” The Western Star, 30 Jan. 1902, pp. 7–7, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/27283. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Free Again.” The Western Star, 15 May 1902, pp. 5–5, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/26996. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Grand Jury Has Stites Murder.” Xenia Daily Gazette , 2 Feb. 1902, pp. 1–1, https://access-newspaperarchive-com.research.cincinnatilibrary.org/us/ohio/xenia/xenia-daily-gazette/1902/02-07/page-1. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Hearing of Richard Ralston for the Stites Murder.” Hamilton Daily Democrat, 24 June 1902, pp. 7–7, https://access-newspaperarchive-com.research.cincinnatilibrary.org/us/ohio/hamilton/hamilton-daily-democrat/1902/06-24/page-7. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“In Justice Court.” The Western Star, 4 Aug. 1898, pp. 5–5, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/25038. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Is Tyler Wanted on Another Indictment.” The Western Star, 21 June 1900, pp. 1–1, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/26138. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Murder Mystery Being Unraveled.” Xenia Daily Gazette and Torchlight, 21 June 1902, pp. 1–1, https://access-newspaperarchive-com.research.cincinnatilibrary.org/us/ohio/xenia/xenia-daily-gazette-and-torchlight/1902/06-21/page-1. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Nice Fat Fees from the Public Crib.” The Western Star, 14 June 1900, pp. 6–6, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/25954. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Not Guilty.” The Western Star, 6 Mar. 1902, pp. 2–2, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/27038. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Preliminary Trial.” The Western Star, 10 May 1900, pp. 2–2, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/26094. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Probable Clew.” The Western Star, 3 May 1900, pp. 2–2, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/26076. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Ralston Was Bound over for the Stites Murder.” Hamilton Daily Democrat, 25 June 1902, pp. 9–9, https://access-newspaperarchive-com.research.cincinnatilibrary.org/us/ohio/hamilton/hamilton-telegraph/1902/07-03/page-9. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Richard Henry Rolston (1830-1912) – Find a Grave…” Find a Grave, 25 Feb. 2024, http://www.findagrave.com/memorial/265575288/richard_henry-rolston.
“Significant Statement by Judge Runyan.” The Western Star, Oct. 2018, pp. 2–2, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/26787. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Stites Murder Again Recalled.” The Western Star, 8 Nov. 1900, pp. 8–8, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/25938. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Stites Murder Suspects.” The Western Star, 13 Feb. 1902, pp. 2–2, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/27242. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Upton Indicted for First Degree Murder.” The Western Star, 31 May 1900, pp. 2–2, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/26274. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Upton Is Free.” The Western Star, 5 July 1900, pp. 2–2, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/26085. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Vernon Lewis Convicted of Perjury.” The Western Star, 19 June 1902, pp. 2–2, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/27215. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Was It Murder?” The Western Star, 23 Aug. 1900, pp. 2–2, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/26058. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“Waynesville Enterprise.” Xenia Daily Gazette, 28 Nov. 1903, pp. 15–15, https://access-newspaperarchive-com.research.cincinnatilibrary.org/us/ohio/xenia/xenia-daily-gazette/1903/11-28/page-15. Accessed Oct. 2025.
The Western Star, 1 May 1902, pp. 4–4, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/27085. Accessed Oct. 2025.
The Western Star, 26 June 1902, pp. 4–4, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/27199. Accessed Oct. 2025.
“‘Col’ Ralston out on Bail. Stites Suspect Temporarily Free.” The Western Star, 3 July 1902, pp. 1–1, https://ohiomemory.org/digital/collection/p16007coll84/id/26956. Accessed Oct. 2025.



























































